The Fox Hollow Murders: Playground of a Serial Killer2025
Created by Alex Jablonski
The premise
Hamilton County coroner Jeff Jellison launches a new investigation into Herb Baumeister decades after thousands of bones were found in the woods behind Fox Hollow Farms, Baumeister's stately home. Using new DNA technology, Jellison and his team work to identify the human remains, bringing long-deferred closure to victims' families and unearthing unsettling questions about potential accomplices, missing evidence, and a key witness whose story keeps changing.
Horror Vault's take
Decades after a grisly discovery on the grounds of a seemingly ordinary Indiana estate, Hamilton County coroner Jeff Jellison reopens one of the Midwest's most disturbing serial killer cases. Armed with cutting-edge DNA technology, Jellison and his team race to put names to the nameless — and in doing so, begin pulling at threads that suggest the full truth may never have been told. The series balances forensic procedural rigor with deeply human portraits of families still waiting for answers. What emerges is as much an indictment of systemic gaps as it is a chronicle of one killer's reign.
Content: Discussion Of Serial Murder, Human Remains And Bone Recovery, Distressing Accounts From Victims' Families
Episode Guide
S1.E1 · The Lost BoysPremiere6.0Feb 18, 2025 · 56 min
When human remains are found at Fox Hollow Farm, investigators uncover how a wealthy businessman preyed on vulnerable gay men.
S1.E2 · A House with Good Bones7.0Feb 18, 2025 · 51 min
Fox Hollow Farm's new owner makes an introduction that raises questions about what really happened, and if a serial killer acted alone.
S1.E3 · Answer the Riddle7.0Feb 18, 2025 · 49 min
Cold case investigator Steve Ainsworth reexamines evidence, uncovering new clues about a potential accomplice in the Fox Hollow Farm murders.
S1.E4 · No Longer Forgotten7.0Feb 28, 2025 · 53 min
As new evidence emerges, a survivor recounts his experience with killer Herb Baumeister.
S1.E5 · Return to Fox Hollow: New Victims, Darker SecretsJul 8, 2026 · 68 min
"Return to Fox Hollow" deepens the investigation with new evidence and explosive revelations.
Where to stream
Cast
Explore related
Ratings & reviews
No reviews yet — be the first to pass judgment.
Sign in to rate this title and warn (or tempt) the next viewer.
More like this
Dexter: Resurrection
2025
The Twilight Zone
1959 · 25m
True Detective
2014
Black Mirror
2011
Twin Peaks
1990
MINDHUNTER
2017
Dexter
2006 · 60m
The X-Files
1993