
Sub-genre
Supernatural
🌫 Every supernatural title worth your dread, gathered and ranked by the Crypt Score — our audience-first blend of IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and viewer reviews.
2239 titles

The Rage: Carrie 2
›R1999 · Horror, Thriller, Science Fiction · 105m · Emily Bergl, Jason London, Amy Irving
A horrible massacre strikes up after an outcast teenage girl is taunted by a group of high school jocks, all of them unaware of her cutthroat telekinetic powers.

Rattlesnake
›2019 · Thriller, Drama, Mystery · 85m · Carmen Ejogo, Theo Rossi, Emma Greenwell
After a mysterious woman saves her daughter from a deadly snakebite, a single mother must repay the debt by killing a stranger before sundown.

Darkness
›PG-132002 · Horror · 88m · Anna Paquin, Lena Olin, Iain Glen
A teenage girl moves into a remote country home with her family, only to discover that the gloomy old house has a horrifying past that threatens to destroy them.

The Vault
›2017 · Horror, Thriller · 91m · James Franco, Taryn Manning, Francesca Eastwood
Two estranged sisters are forced to rob a bank in order to save their brother. But this is no ordinary bank.

The Veil
›NR2016 · Horror · 93m · Jessica Alba, Thomas Jane, Lily Rabe
30 years ago, when members of a religious cult known as Heaven's Veil take their own lives. The truth behind what really happened remains buried deep in the memory of the sole survivor, a five-year-old girl. Now as an adult she returns to the compound with a documentary crew. They soon discover something that is far more terrifying than anything they could have imagined.

At the Devil's Door
›R2014 · Horror · 91m · Ashley Rickards, Nick Eversman, Michael Massee
When ambitious young real estate agent Leigh is asked to sell a house with a checkered past, she crosses paths with a disturbed girl whom she learns is the runaway daughter of the couple selling the property. When Leigh tries to intervene and help her, she becomes entangled with a supernatural force that soon pulls Leigh's artist sister Vera into its web - and has sinister plans for both of them.

Another Me
›PG-132013 · Thriller, Mystery, Horror · 86m · Sophie Turner, Claire Forlani, Rhys Ifans
A teenager finds her perfect life upended when she's stalked by a mysterious doppelganger who has her eyes set on assuming her identity.

The Assent
›2020 · Horror, Thriller · 89m · Robert Kazinsky, Peter Jason, Hannah Ward
After a series of disturbing supernatural events in his home, Joel a young single father, comes to suspect that his young son may be possessed. Soon Joel receives a visit from Father Lambert, a controversial exorcist in town whose last patient died during his treatment. As increasing chilling occurrences begin to unfold, the priest informs a resistant Joel that unless he can successfully perform an exorcism, the devil will soon take full control of his boy.

Boogeyman 3
›NR2008 · Horror, Thriller · 94m · Erin Cahill, Chuck Hittinger, Mimi Michaels
When a college student witnesses the alleged suicide of her roommate, it sets into motion a series of horrific events that cause her to fear the supernatural entity. As she tries to convince the rest of her dorm that the Boogeyman does exist, the evil force grows stronger and her friends begin to pay the price. Now she must stop this ultimate evil before the entire campus falls prey.

The Exorcism of Molly Hartley
›2015 · Horror · 96m · Sarah Lind, Devon Sawa, Gina Holden
Accused of murder and confined to a mental institution, Molly Hartley falls under the possession of a powerful demonic force. As she undergoes a monstrous transformation, a defrocked priest is her only hope of salvation.

A Nun's Curse
›2020 · Horror · 73m · Felissa Rose, Damian Maffei, Erika Arlee
A group of travelers are forced to seek shelter inside an abandoned jail where a notorious nun named Sister Monday had once been assigned and was suspected of murdering prisoners.

Slumber Party Massacre II
›R1987 · Horror, Comedy · 76m · Crystal Bernard, Jennifer Rhodes, Kimberly McArthur
Courtney is tormented by dreams of the infamous Driller Killer returning to wreak havoc... only to find that the murderous monster is reincarnated as an evil rocker.

The Monster Project
›2017 · Action, Horror · 98m · Yvonne Zima, Justin Bruening, Toby Hemingway
A group of aspiring filmmakers interview three individuals who claim to be monsters. However, unique incidents start to occur when they start filming.

The Final Wish
›R2019 · Horror · 95m · Lin Shaye, Michael Welch, Melissa Bolona
Following the passing of his father, Aaron Hammond returns to his hometown to help his devastated mother and to confront his past demons. Sifting through his father’s belongings, Aaron comes upon a mysterious item that is far more than it seems.

Cellar Door
›R2024 · Horror, Thriller · 97m · Jordana Brewster, Scott Speedman, Laurence Fishburne
Looking for a fresh start after a miscarriage, a couple find themselves being gifted the house of their dreams with one caveat - they can never open the cellar door. Whether they can live without knowing triggers shocking consequences.

Amityville 1992: It's About Time
›R1992 · Horror · 94m · Stephen Macht, Shawn Weatherly, Megan Ward
A hot-shot architect returns home from his latest business trip with a surprise: an ornate old clock rescued out of a soon-to-be-demolished mansion in Amityville, New York, that brings about a seemingly unstoppable demonic force.

Bingo Hell
›NR2021 · Thriller, Horror · 85m · Adriana Barraza, L. Scott Caldwell, Joshua Caleb Johnson
In the barrio of Oak Springs lives a strong and stubborn group of elderly friends who refuse to be gentrified. Their leader, Lupita, keeps them together as a community, a family. But little did they know, their beloved bingo hall is about to be sold to a much more powerful force than money itself.

The Abandoned
›2015 · Thriller, Horror, Mystery · 86m · Jason Patric, Louisa Krause, Mark Margolis
A troubled young woman who, in a last-ditch effort at getting her life together, takes a job working nights as a security guard at an abandoned luxury apartment building. Stuck with a brusque rent-a-cop as her partner, she tries to not let her mind play tricks on her while she patrols the empty halls. But as the night progresses strange things begin to happen - and she realizes it may not all be in her head.

The Car: Road to Revenge
›2019 · Action, Horror, Thriller · 89m · Grant Bowler, Kathleen Munroe, Martin Hancock
In a dilapidated cyberpunk city plagued by crime and corruption, an unscrupulous District Attorney is savagely murdered and tossed out of a building onto his brand new car. Mysteriously, the District Attorney and his car come back to life as a single being with a thirst for vengeance. The eerie driverless car embarks on a vicious rampage, exacting revenge on the criminals who murdered him...

The Sandman
›2017 · Horror · 90m · Haylie Duff, Tobin Bell, Shaun Sipos
A monster from a little girl's nightmares comes to life and attacks anyone who would harm her.

The Nanny
›2018 · Science Fiction, Thriller, Horror · 80m · Jaime Murray, Nicholas Brendon, Schuyler Fisk
Young Noa and Michael are put in the care of their new nanny, Leonor, who Noa suspects is a malicious supernatural being. Dismissed by those around her, Noa works to uncover Leonor's true identity, but soon finds herself with far more than she bargained for.

The Stranger
›2014 · Thriller, Horror, Mystery · 93m · Lorenza Izzo, Ariel Levy, Aaron Burns
A supernatural thriller, laced by flashbacks, and set in Canada’s North-West, “The Stranger” turns on the mysterious titular figure of Martin, who comes to a small quiet town seeking to kill his wife Ana who suffers from a very dangerous decease that makes her addicted to human blood - just like himself-. However, when he arrives to the town, he discovers that Ana has been dead for a couple of years and decides to commit suicide to definitely eradicate this dangerous decease, but, before he can do it, Martin's brutally attacked by three local thugs led by Caleb, the son of a corrupt police lieutenant, and the incident suddenly starts a snowball that will plunge the community into a bloodbath.

Discarnate
›2019 · Horror, Thriller · 84m · Thomas Kretschmann, Nadine Velazquez, Josh Stewart
A neuroscientist's obsession with a drug that expands the human mind inadvertently unleashes a deadly supernatural force on his team.

Dead Again in Tombstone
›R2017 · Western, Action, Fantasy · 99m · Danny Trejo, Jake Busey, Elysia Rotaru
The devil’s outlaw and reluctant servant, Guerrero returns from the dead again in this action-packed western which promises to be one hell of a ride. Guerrero is forced to protect a stolen relic from getting into the hands of Jackson Boomer and his gang of soldiers, but Jackson will stop at nothing to raise his comrades from the dead and bring the wrath of hell upon earth. Guerrero must use all his dark powers in order to defeat Jackson and find redemption…or die again trying.
